Wednesday, November 10, 2010

Off Season, Off Topic - Jeter's Gold Glove

Derek Jeter won the Gold Glove yesterday. Here's what him winning means to me:

1) I don't hate Derek Jeter, the person. I don't know him. I'm sure he's a fine human. Who am I to know or to judge? But I do hate the Yankees and I hate perception of Derek Jeter. This Gold Glove win validates my feelings.

How do you win a Gold Glove in the same week that people are writing articles about whether it's time for you to find a new position? There's only one way: your name is Derek Jeter and people's opinions of you are so super-inflated that you are immune to the abundant negative facts about your play. Like...

Derek Jeter is clutch, even though he has never been amongst the leaders for RBIs after the 7th inning that tie or take the lead.

Derek Jeter is clutch in the playoffs, even though is overall playoff numbers are relatively the same or in some categories worse than his regular season numbers.

Derek Jeter is the ideal leader and winner in baseball, even though he is the only team captain to have his team lose a 3-0 lead in the playoffs.

Derek Jeter is a Gold Glove winner even though his range is subjectively (everyone knows he's as slow as shit) and objectively (UZR) one of the league's worst.

And despite hitting .270/.340/.370 with rapidly deteriorating defensive skills, he'll get $15-20 million per year for 3-4 years.

Of course, who needs stats and facts. Certainly not Jeter himself, who once told Sports Illustrated, "You can take those stat guys and throw them out the window."

That's right, nothing to see here. Keep moving people...

I hate "Derek Jeter."

2) The Gold Glove is a joke. We all already knew this. Ever since Bobby Abreu won one and Rafael Palmeiro won one after only playing 28 games of defense. We really can't be upset now that Jeter won his 5th. It's a farce and should be treated as so.

However, it's still wrong and it is a legitimate organization pretending to give out a legitimate award. Giving Jeter this award is like the Academy giving a "Best Picture" Oscar to "Howard The Duck." Or the Insane Clown Posse winning a Grammy.

3) The American League managers and coaches who voted for Derek Jeter should be ashamed. I don't necessarily expect guys like Ron Washington or Joe Maddon to be checking the UZR leaderboard before voting but they should have enough common baseball knowledge and perceptive abilities to see that Jeter roamed short like a constipated old lady.

I would suggest the voting should go to somebody else but who? The fans vote everything on popularity. And so do the baseball writers, for that matter. I'm starting to think they should just come up with some sort of Sabermetric formula and skip voting all together.

11 comments:

GM-Carson said...

Jeter won the Gold Glove? Wow! Earlier in his career he was an excellent shortstop and actually deserved some of the Gold Gloves, but certainly not this year. I hate Gold Gloves. They used to mean something, like when Ozzie "The Wizard" Smith won a ton of them.

Off the top of my head, it's hard to say who probably deserved the Gold Glove at SS. Jack Wilson and Adam Everett are defensive whizzes, but were hurt most of the season. Tampa's Jason Bartlett is good and the Royals' Yunesky Betantcourt is good too, but neither hit enough.

audittrida said...

but it is the gold glove not gold bat. alot of people ive talked to mentioned elvis andrus

SirAlden said...

Four Words:

Bobby Abreu Gold Glove.

GM-Carson said...

2 words:

Read post.

Dr. Steve said...

Like... don't we have defensive statistics? Shouldn't they at least limit who is eligible for the Gold Glove? I don't understand how Jeter won.

GM-Carson said...

From ESPN.com:

Worst Plus-Minus Among Qualified Shortstops, 2010 Season (Min. 400 Innings)
Yuniesky Betancourt, KC -15
Derek Jeter, NYY -13
Marco Scutaro, BOS -5
Asdrubal Cabrera, CLE -5

Worst UZR/150 Among Qualified Shortstops, 2010 Season
Jason Bartlett, TB -13.8
Yuniesky Betancourt, KC -9.2
Derek Jeter, NYY -5.4
Marco Scutaro, BOS -3.3

GM-Carson said...

Victorino just won his 3rd straight NL Gold Glove. Wonder if we can trade him and Blanton somewhere to free up some money to sign Werth and Lee.

Andrew said...

and Utley snubbed once again. I agree that GGs are pretty meaningless, but at the same time, Utley deserves to have like 3 right now, not zero.

GM-Carson said...

According to UZR and other new fielding stats, Utley has been one of the best fielding players in the majors over the past few years, not just secondbase.

Anonymous said...

To get an alternative Steelers Jersey [url=http://www.robertgriffiniiijerseynike.com/]Robert Griffin III Jersey[/url]
a first-class idea because not necessarily only the jersey on the well-liked team which keeps its routine performance to the mark[url=http://www.peytonmanningjerseynike.com/]Authentic Peyton Manning Jersey[/url]
the jersey of the team also involve some quality in the ideaWearing one of these football jerseys would symbolize a hard core fan at one point of time
[url=http://www.andrewluckwomensjersey.com/]Authentic Andrew Luck Jersey[/url]
Cell phone wholesalers continue to offer th[url=http://www.peytonmanningjerseynike.com/]Elite Peyton Manning Jersey[/url]
somewhat less popular model Clemens acquired emerge from retirement life 3 times as well as for the next[url=http://www.andrewluckwomensjersey.com/]Andrew Luck Jersey[/url]
he'd come back to New York just after absent spring season training as well as the beginning of the period to gather a million cash a start off

Anonymous said...

[url=http://icamtech.com]led lights[/url] [url=http://icamtech.com/led_light_bulbs]led bulbs[/url] [url=http://icamtech.com/led_candles]led candles[/url] [url=http://icamtech.com/led_par_lamp]par20 led[/url] [url=http://icamtech.com/led_flood_light]led flood light[/url] [url=http://icamtech.com]led light[/url]
The original styles by Tiffany have been completely beautiful to educate yourself regarding be on the lookout at but take heart are already rarely to the full ready to learn more about connect with most of them are going to be the state of the art is going to need having to do with an average British household. This has to be that the reason a portion of the leading lighting services or products vendors must pay back taken everywhere in the the task to do with augmenting going to be the original sizes and molding them for more information on suit everyday needs Some give for instance gone ahead for additional details on create Tiffany lamp forms about their surely have,so as to provide an all in one bigger catalog to learn more about going to be the user for more information about gps device back and forth from

[url=http://icamtech.com]led lighting[/url][url=http://icamtech.com]led light[/url][url=http://icamtech.com]led lights[/url]